What’s the REAL Difference Between Roofing Synthetic Underlayments? (East Bay Roofing Guide)

You’ve seen the labels. You’ve heard the pitch. But when every roofer in town recommends a different “best” synthetic underlayment, what’s the real difference?

Here’s the truth: synthetic underlayment is one of the most misunderstood components of a roofing system especially in the East Bay Area, where tile, shingle, and flat roofs all demand serious weather protection.

At Mel’s Roofing, we’re breaking down the facts to help you understand what matters, what doesn’t, and why performance (not branding) should guide your choice.

Why Synthetic Underlayment is Essential in the East Bay

East Bay homes experience everything from summer heat to unexpected winter rain. That makes your roofing underlayment more than just a formality—it’s a critical barrier.

Synthetic underlayment outperforms traditional felt in almost every way. It’s:

• More resistant to water and UV rays

• Safer for installers, thanks to non-slip surfaces

• Stronger and more durable, even under extreme conditions

Whether you’re re-roofing in San Ramon or building a new home in Livermore, this layer matters.

What Do All Synthetic Underlayments Have in Common?

You’ll find many different names on the market from Grip-Rite to Summit to ProArmor but here’s the key insight:

Most synthetic underlayments share the same core features:

• 100 GSM or higher thickness

• Slip-resistant surface

• Compliance with ASTM and California codes

• Exposure time of up to 90 days

  
  

That means they’ll perform nearly identically during installation and under roofing materials, whether you’re using asphalt shingles or clay tile.

What Should You Actually Look For?

Rather than focusing on brand names or packaging, pay attention to the elements that directly impact roof performance and safety.

1. Grip and Safety

Roofs in cities like Pleasanton and Fremont often have steep slopes. Non-slip surfaces help crews work more safely, especially in early morning dew or light rain.

2. Thickness (GSM Rating)

Look for a minimum of 100 GSM. This ensures durability during install and strength under roofing layers.

3. Code Compliance

All materials installed by Mel’s Roofing meet California state and local building codes, including ASTM and Florida approvals.

4. UV and Weather Resistance

If inspections or weather delays occur, it’s important that underlayment can hold up under sun and wind for weeks without degrading.

Most Common East Bay Roofing Systems & Compatibility

Different neighborhoods in the East Bay lean toward different roof styles—but synthetic underlayment works under all of them when chosen correctly:

• Asphalt Shingles – Common in residential areas like Tracy or Mountain House

• Tile Roofing (Clay or Concrete) – Popular in Danville, San Ramon, and Walnut Creek

• Flat Roof Systems – Used in commercial buildings and some modern homes

The key isn’t which product is on the label—it’s whether your contractor installs it correctly and uses materials rated for your climate and roof type.

FAQ: What East Bay Homeowners Should Know

Can synthetic underlayment be exposed to the sun?

Yes, most allow for up to 90 days of UV exposure, which helps during inspections or delays but full coverage should still happen quickly.

Does every roof need synthetic underlayment?

Absolutely. It protects the decking and interior from wind-driven rain, especially important in areas like Walnut Creek where storm patterns can shift quickly.

Is thicker always better?

Not always. Anything above 100 GSM is considered standard for durability. Past that, it’s about matching the material to the roof type and slope.

Ask Yourself This:

If all underlayments meet code, resist slipping, and support your roofing system, what really makes one better than the other?

The answer lies in proper selection and installation. At Mel’s Roofing, we prioritize efficiency, safety, and local compatibility—not hype.

Roofing Services Near Me? Trust Mel’s Roofing in the East Bay

Whether you’re in Dublin, Fremont, or San Ramon, Mel’s Roofing is here to help you make smart, informed choices for your home.

We use high-performance synthetic underlayments that check all the boxes—resistant, reliable, and region-ready. No gimmicks. Just results that last.

👉 Need an inspection or want to plan your next roofing project? Contact Mel’s Roofing today for expert service backed by experience across the East Bay.

Check Out This Roof Leak Repair!